New York Democrats are fining unvaccinated Amish children $2,000 per day, as viral social media posts alleged in October 2026.
<div class="rating_wrapper">
<span class="wrapper_title">Rating:</span>
<a id="main_rating" class="rating_link_wrapper" href="https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/rating/mixture">
<div class="rating_img_wrap">
<img class="lazy-image" src="https://mediaproxy.snopes.com/width/200/https://media.snopes.com/2018/03/rating-mixture.png" alt="Mixture"/>
</div>
</a>
</div>
<div id="outer_fact_context" class="outer_fact_check_context">
<div class="fact_check_info_wrapper">
<span class="fact_check_info_title">What's True</span>
<p class="fact_check_info_description">In 2022, the state of New York penalized three Amish schools for violating a statute requiring all enrolled students to maintain up-to-date immunizations, a rule enacted after religious exemptions were eliminated in 2019. These institutions were assessed a penalty of $2,000 daily for each student lacking required vaccinations, accumulating $118,000 in total before initiating legal action against the state.</p>
</div>
<div class="fact_check_info_wrapper">
<span class="fact_check_info_title">What's False</span>
<p class="fact_check_info_description">The financial penalties were levied against the schools themselves, not against individual children.</p>
</div>
<div class="fact_check_info_wrapper">
<span class="fact_check_info_title">What's Undetermined</span>
<p class="fact_check_info_description">State health officials have not clarified whether additional schools have faced similar penalties or if the original three institutions have continued to accrue fines past 2022.</p>
</div>
</div>
</section>
<input type="hidden" id="article_url" value="/fact-check/new-york-unvaccinated-amish-children/"/>
<p>Viral online discussions in October suggested that New York had "declared war on the Amish" through strict enforcement of vaccine mandates via punitive financial measures. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/04/us/amish-vaccines-measles.html">Numerous Amish communities</a> traditionally maintain <a href="https://publications.aap.org/aapnews/news/13905/Study-Low-vaccination-rate-in-Amish-children">lower childhood immunization rates</a> compared to the broader U.S. populace, though immunization is not universally banned within these groups.</p>
<p>A widely circulated <a href="https://www.facebook.com/bluematters/posts/pfbid0ipCrJUKP33VbtyVkwfAbwfyAiUTrc26GpaQR22PYGE91TZAwPjoTBNkzuFktY6Eml">Facebook post</a> (<a href="https://perma.cc/9GSW-2YAC?type=image">archived</a>) alleged that the state government was charging every unvaccinated Amish child a daily fee of $2,000, attributing the policy to state Democrats who had previously revoked the religious exemptions families relied upon.</p>Similar allegations surfaced across Instagram (archived) and X (archived), prompting readers to seek verification regarding the accuracy of these claims.
While the state did penalize at least three Amish schools $2,000 per day for every non-compliant student in attendance, the penalties targeted the educational institutions rather than individual children. Furthermore, it remains uncertain whether these fines remain active. Consequently, the assertion is categorized as a mixture of accurate and inaccurate elements.
These specifics are documented in the ongoing legal challenge, Miller v. McDonald.
Court documents show that New York rescinded religious exemptions for school vaccinations in 2019—affecting public, private, and religious schools alike—following measles outbreaks in 2018 and 2019 linked to pockets of unimmunized populations (PDF Page 3).
During the 2019 legislative session, the Democratic party held majorities in both the state Senate and Assembly, while Andrew Cuomo, a Democrat, served as governor.
The state immunization statute explicitly bars schools from permitting unimmunized children to attend classes until they meet required health standards. Following an audit of three Amish schools in 2021, the state issued fines the following year for allowing non-compliant students to participate in in-person learning (PDF Page 7).
Statutory guidelines mandate a $2,000 penalty for each daily violation (PDF pages 7-8), with every unimmunized student counted as a separate daily infraction. Before issuing the penalties, authorities sent formal warnings to administrators.
State calculations assumed two schools committed single-day violations and a third school operated with one non-compliant student for 10 days. This calculation yielded penalties of $52,000 for 26 students at one location, $46,000 for 23 students at a second, and $20,000 for a single student at the third, bringing the cumulative total to $118,000.
This $118,000 figure represents the aggregate penalties cited in the initial June 2023 lawsuit, subsequent judicial opinions, and recent public discussions. Legal representatives for the affected schools highlighted this exact total when announcing plans to bring the case before the U.S. Supreme Court on October 2.
In response to inquiries regarding ongoing penalties or additional school enforcement, the New York State Department of Health did not provide specific figures. A departmental spokesperson shared the following statement via email:
The state’s responsibility is to protect public health, keep New Yorkers and their families safe and enforce the law fairly and equitably. While we cannot comment on pending litigation, the Department is committed to eliminating serious illness and unnecessary deaths caused by vaccine preventable diseases. The Department continues to provide community outreach and education on the safety of immunizations. New York’s school immunization requirements are based in science and protect the health and well-being of all New Yorkers.
The legal challenge, which argues the mandate infringes upon religious liberties, has moved through multiple judicial levels. Although the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the state in 2025 (PDF Page 5), the U.S. Supreme Court later vacated that ruling and directed a review based on a separate precedent.
Upon reconsideration, the 2nd Circuit maintained its original stance in Miller v. McDonald. This June 30 ruling is the decision currently being appealed to the Supreme Court.